Accounting Talk
Accounting Talk
 
 FAQFAQ   SearchSearch   MemberlistMemberlist   UsergroupsUsergroups   RegisterRegister 
 ProfileProfile   Log in to check your private messagesLog in to check your private messages   Log inLog in 

Quicken and bank downloads

 
Post new topic   Reply to topic    Accounting Talk Forum Index -> Quicken
View previous topic :: View next topic  
Author Message
Bernie Cosell
Guest





PostPosted: Sun Jul 13, 2008 4:14 pm    Post subject: Quicken and bank downloads Reply with quote

I'm thinking of opening an account with a new bank, and they tell me that
they don't support "direct connect" -- I gather that's the magic that
allows Quicken to pick up transactions from the bank by itself with "one
step update". I'm trying to understand what that'll mean if I do go with
the bank. Is this the correct sequence of events:

1) Fire up quicken and make sure it is pointing at the right account[*]
2) Fire up browser
3) go to bank's website [waitwaitwait]
4) log in [waitwaitwait]
5) navigate to the place to get quicken downloads [waitwaitwait]
6) Do the download [wait wait] and tell Windows "open the file" --
just "open"ing it will feed the info to quicken, right? [if
quicken is currently looking at the right account]
7) log off the bank website

Repeat 3-7 for each such bank.

[*] I use quicken to manage several "separate" sets of accounts: one is
my personal stuff, another several are small clubs for which I'm
treasurer, another is a set of accounts that I need to keep separate
from my personal ones [for legal reasons], etc. So when I start
quicken, unless I double click on the right QEF file it is a bit hard
to predict which of those sets-of-accounts it'll be looking at when it
starts.

Anyhow, is that about close? Is there no way to automate it? It seems
truly awful [especially so because I'm on a SLOW internet connection [in
some ways it sucks to live in the middle of nowhere]] I can't imagine
doing that for each of the nine accounts I have in my 'personal' account
set every time I want to bring things up to date [compared with click
"update" and going away and doing something else for ten minutes].
[basically, if it really is that ugly I'll likely just go with a different
bank that _does_ allow "direct connect"] Thanks!

/Bernie\
--
Bernie Cosell Fantasy Farm Fibers
bernie@fantasyfarm.com Pearisburg, VA
--> Too many people, too few sheep <--
Back to top
  Ads
Advertising
Sponsor


Han
Guest





PostPosted: Sun Jul 13, 2008 5:24 pm    Post subject: Re: Quicken and bank downloads Reply with quote

Bernie Cosell <bernie@fantasyfarm.com> wrote in
news:o8oj74pk1scj8jfhd30pa57knk7jjrejqp@library.airnews.net:

There are multiple questions here, so bear with me, and see below in
line.

Quote:
I'm thinking of opening an account with a new bank, and they tell me
that they don't support "direct connect" -- I gather that's the magic
that allows Quicken to pick up transactions from the bank by itself
with "one step update".

There is direct connect and there is web connect. As I understand it,
with Q2008 the difference is minimal, and One Step Update (OSU) does
both. But then, the proof of the pudding is in the eating.

Quote:
I'm trying to understand what that'll mean if
I do go with the bank. Is this the correct sequence of events:

1) Fire up quicken and make sure it is pointing at the right
account[*] 2) Fire up browser
3) go to bank's website [waitwaitwait]
4) log in [waitwaitwait]
5) navigate to the place to get quicken downloads [waitwaitwait]
6) Do the download [wait wait] and tell Windows "open the file" --
just "open"ing it will feed the info to quicken, right? [if
quicken is currently looking at the right account]
7) log off the bank website

Repeat 3-7 for each such bank.

That seems right, but some of the wait steps will often be there also if
you do OSU. Keep in mind that the servers that Quicken uses at your FI
are most likely different then he server tat serves up your account data
via the web. In my experience, the Quicken servers are often behind by
24 hrs or so. So often I let Quicken downoad via OSU, then go and check
the banks' websites.

Quote:
[*] I use quicken to manage several "separate" sets of accounts:
one is my personal stuff, another several are small clubs for which
I'm treasurer, another is a set of accounts that I need to keep
separate from my personal ones [for legal reasons], etc. So when
I start quicken, unless I double click on the right QEF file it
is a bit hard to predict which of those sets-of-accounts it'll be
looking at when it starts.

Correction, it is the QDF file that is the main file in te file set.
Making shortcuts in your desktop or quicklaunch folder to these various
QDF files and double clicking them would launch Quicken with the
respective fileset. No double checking necessary (not that
doublechecking is bad <grin>). You can change the icons to make it
clearer which shortcut is which.

Quote:
Anyhow, is that about close? Is there no way to automate it? It
seems truly awful [especially so because I'm on a SLOW internet
connection [in some ways it sucks to live in the middle of nowhere]]

You could set your browser to log on to a bunch of your banking sites
simultaneously. Most browsers now have that ability either in separate
tabs, or separate windows.

Quote:
I can't imagine doing that for each of the nine accounts I have in my
'personal' account set every time I want to bring things up to date
[compared with click "update" and going away and doing something else
for ten minutes]. [basically, if it really is that ugly I'll likely
just go with a different bank that _does_ allow "direct connect"]
Thanks!

/Bernie\

My preference would be banks that support what I really want to do. It
may be that you get a discount of sorts if you bring all your accounts to
a new bank (or threaten the old bank that you will take all your business
elsewhere if they don't acomodate you). They can always tell you to go
and ... <grin>.

--
Best regards
Han
email address is invalid
Back to top
  Ads
Advertising
Sponsor


John Pollard
Guest





PostPosted: Sun Jul 13, 2008 6:04 pm    Post subject: Re: Quicken and bank downloads Reply with quote

Bernie Cosell wrote:
Quote:
I'm thinking of opening an account with a new bank, and they
tell me
that they don't support "direct connect" -- I gather that's
the magic
that allows Quicken to pick up transactions from the bank by
itself
with "one step update". I'm trying to understand what that'll
mean
if I do go with the bank. Is this the correct sequence of
events:

1) Fire up quicken and make sure it is pointing at the right
account[*] 2) Fire up browser
3) go to bank's website [waitwaitwait]
4) log in [waitwaitwait]
5) navigate to the place to get quicken downloads
[waitwaitwait]
6) Do the download [wait wait] and tell Windows "open the
file" --
just "open"ing it will feed the info to quicken, right?
[if
quicken is currently looking at the right account]
7) log off the bank website

That sequence will get you what you want, but some of it isn't
necessary, and in some cases, there will be extra steps.

You don't have to "filre up browser"; if you tell Quicken to
"update" a Web Connect account, Quicken will fire up its
internal browser and present you with the sign-in page for your
fi.

You will have to sign-in then navigate to the page for
downloading and initiate the download. (*)

You do not have to "save" the download in a file; during the
download you can be asked whether to "save" the download (to a
disk file) or to "open" the download: opening the download will
put the downloaded transactions into the Quicken "Accept
transactions into register" window - no "import" step is
necessary in this case.

Quote:
Repeat 3-7 for each such bank.

(*) For some financial institutions, you will have to repeat
5-6 for each account held there.

Quote:
[*] I use quicken to manage several "separate" sets of
accounts:
one is my personal stuff, another several are small clubs
for
which I'm treasurer, another is a set of accounts that I
need to
keep separate from my personal ones [for legal reasons],
etc. So
when I start quicken, unless I double click on the right
QEF file
it is a bit hard to predict which of those
sets-of-accounts it'll
be looking at when it starts.

Anyhow, is that about close? Is there no way to automate it?

Starting with Q2008, Quicken offers what it calls "Express Web
Connect": it's intended to allow you to download from Web
Connect accounts using One Step Update. It expects to "screen
scrape" your data; that is, it attempts to do steps 2-6 for you,
and when it works, it definitely improves the downloading
experience over plain Web Connect.

But Express Web Connect does not always work; I believe the
primary culprit is something called Multi-Factor Authentication,
whose effect you may be familiar with, even if not the name.

Over the past couple of years, your financial institutions have
likely modified their login procedure to require more than just
a password (sometimes much more*) and begun using different
(separate) web pages to collect the info. I think that the
screen scraping software is having problems dealing with some of
the implementations of MFA (each fi can choose from several
different approaches to MFA).

[* One way that MFA can almost certainly defeat screen scraping
is to present an image containing numbers and letters that can
only be read by a human and to require the person logging in to
enter that same combination of numbers and letters. If your fi
requires that as part of its MFA (or your fi offers it, and you
have chosen to use it), I'm fairly certain you will not be able
to use Express Web Connect with that fi.]

I can't tell you what problems you may face with your new fi,
but if you post their name, perhaps others here can tell you
whether they have been able to use Express Web Connect with that
fi. [The fi must agree to allow Express Web Connect, so you
could ask your fi if they permit it. But even if they permit
EWC, it may not work ... see above.]

--

John Pollard
First initial underscore Last name at mchsi dot com
Please reply to newsgroup
Back to top
  Ads
Advertising
Sponsor


Bernie Cosell
Guest





PostPosted: Mon Jul 14, 2008 11:02 am    Post subject: Re: Quicken and bank downloads Reply with quote

"John Pollard" <invalid@invalid.com> wrote:

} Bernie Cosell wrote:
} > I'm thinking of opening an account with a new bank, and they
} > tell me
} > that they don't support "direct connect" -- I gather that's
} > the magic
} > that allows Quicken to pick up transactions from the bank by
} > itself
} > with "one step update".

} You don't have to "filre up browser"; if you tell Quicken to
} "update" a Web Connect account, Quicken will fire up its
} internal browser and present you with the sign-in page for your
} fi.
}
} You will have to sign-in then navigate to the page for
} downloading and initiate the download. (*)

Cleaner than having to switch back and forth from quicken to the browser,
but still a bit of a pain [since I'm tied to sitting there and clicking and
typing while all this slow-crap is going on].

} > Anyhow, is that about close? Is there no way to automate it?
}
} Starting with Q2008, Quicken offers what it calls "Express Web
} Connect": it's intended to allow you to download from Web
} Connect accounts using One Step Update. It expects to "screen
} scrape" your data; that is, it attempts to do steps 2-6 for you,
} and when it works, it definitely improves the downloading
} experience over plain Web Connect.

Hmm.. Interesting: sounds like enough banks don't support direct-connect
and enough customers griped or something like that, that intuit put in some
machinery to try to help.

} Over the past couple of years, your financial institutions have
} likely modified their login procedure to require more than just
} a password (sometimes much more*) and begun using different
} (separate) web pages to collect the info.

Interesting. I haven't actually investigated in detail what *this* bank's
webpage set up is, so I"m not sure how it'll work out.

} .. I can't tell you what problems you may face with your new fi,
} but if you post their name, perhaps others here can tell you
} whether they have been able to use Express Web Connect with that
} fi. [The fi must agree to allow Express Web Connect, so you
} could ask your fi if they permit it. But even if they permit
} EWC, it may not work ... see above.]

Cool. The bank I'm *considering* is StellarOne. But it sounds iffy enough
[and I don't have q2008 yet!] so I'm probably just going to go with a not
quite so convenient bank that *does* allow direct connect [wachovia].

Thanks!
/Bernie\
--
Bernie Cosell Fantasy Farm Fibers
bernie@fantasyfarm.com Pearisburg, VA
--> Too many people, too few sheep <--
Back to top
  Ads
Advertising
Sponsor


Bernie Cosell
Guest





PostPosted: Mon Jul 14, 2008 11:02 am    Post subject: Re: Quicken and bank downloads Reply with quote

Han <nobody@nospam.not> wrote:

} Bernie Cosell <bernie@fantasyfarm.com> wrote in
} news:o8oj74pk1scj8jfhd30pa57knk7jjrejqp@library.airnews.net:

}
} > I'm thinking of opening an account with a new bank, and they tell me
} > that they don't support "direct connect" -- I gather that's the magic
} > that allows Quicken to pick up transactions from the bank by itself
} > with "one step update".
}
} There is direct connect and there is web connect. As I understand it,
} with Q2008 the difference is minimal, and One Step Update (OSU) does
} both. But then, the proof of the pudding is in the eating.

Ah, I'm still at Q2006 but this might be a reason to upgrade!

} > Repeat 3-7 for each such bank.
}
} That seems right, but some of the wait steps will often be there also if
} you do OSU.

Yes, but with OSU *I'M* not sitting there. I click OSU, minimize Quicken
and either do something else or go away for a while.

} > Anyhow, is that about close? Is there no way to automate it? It
} > seems truly awful [especially so because I'm on a SLOW internet
} > connection [in some ways it sucks to live in the middle of nowhere]]
}
} You could set your browser to log on to a bunch of your banking sites
} simultaneously. Most browsers now have that ability either in separate
} tabs, or separate windows.

Hmm. Mine doesn't. I can set it to *open* a bunch of sites all at the
same time, but it won't fill in passwords, navigate through various pages,
etc. I'll go check! Thanks!

/Bernie\
--
Bernie Cosell Fantasy Farm Fibers
bernie@fantasyfarm.com Pearisburg, VA
--> Too many people, too few sheep <--
Back to top
  Ads
Advertising
Sponsor


Han
Guest





PostPosted: Mon Jul 14, 2008 3:58 pm    Post subject: Re: Quicken and bank downloads Reply with quote

Bernie Cosell <bernie@fantasyfarm.com> wrote in
news:1aam74lk7jsheqnqh10nsongqrv6m8kdpo@library.airnews.net:

Quote:
Hmm. Mine doesn't. I can set it to *open* a bunch of sites all at
the same time, but it won't fill in passwords, navigate through
various pages, etc. I'll go check! Thanks!


I believe that Firefox can do that, but I bought a portable version of
Roboform so I can load everything on a stick and take it with me

--
Best regards
Han
email address is invalid
Back to top
  Ads
Advertising
Sponsor


Display posts from previous:   
Post new topic   Reply to topic    Accounting Talk Forum Index -> Quicken All times are GMT
Page 1 of 1

 
Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum

Australian Debt Consolidation Experts
medical insurance
Wedding Ring
Trova Escort e Accompagnatrici sui portali di annunci (www.EscortForum.com, www.BestAnnunci.com, www.PiccoleTrasgressioni.com ...)
Swingers in Europe
Xpointer Framework
personal secured loans
Make Your Own Website
Cheap phone calls to Pakistan
Cleaning Service
black mold
UK Swingers Genuine Contacts Site
floor machines
bissell Parts


Board Security

67 Attacks blocked

Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group